In
the moments after I left the theater, I had an odd feeling that carried with me
throughout the week. I knew something was off but I just couldn't figure it
out. In my mind I did not want to admit to myself that I disliked a movie that
i believed was going to galvanize the standard of what all future Batman films
would aspire to be. Then the realization hit that I was truly and utterly
disappointed in The Dark Knight Rises. The film had its moments, but for
multiple reasons it was unable to create the guttural tension I felt while
viewing The Dark Knight. Like a child coping with finding out the tooth fairy
is actually your parents, I was distraught, racking my brain for the real
reason why I didn’t enjoy this film.
But before I get into all the bad shit, here are a couple
things I liked about TDKR.
· The scale and ambition of this movie: Nolan knew
that he had a tough task in topping The Dark Knight. So the stunts and overall
enormity of this project was definenlty amplified and it was good to know that
he was trying to top it.
· Joseph Gordon Levitt: HUGE
SPOILER- he is Robin. Literally his name is Robin. At the end he discovers the
bat cave and it gives you hope that this particular Batman franchise will live
on.
· Catwoman: I though Hathaway did it justice, she
was the first actress to really take a stab at Catwoman in a much more lifelike
and grounded way. Instead of being licked by mythical cats, ala Michelle Pfeifer,
she is more of just a master jewel theif that will stop it nothing to get what
she wants. Well done. (
Ed. Note- this is
how I feel about Hathaway's Catwoman).
Bane: at first I felt that he was hindered in
his performance by the mask. But after further review, I’m starting to come
around and really respect the performance given by Hardy. It was an attempt to
make this generations Darth Vader but kind of fell short into Darth Maul
territory. Not bad, just not the same thing.
Many of the issues I have with this film fall in two
categories. Tension and World of story. This is where I noticed the biggest
drop off from the last film. So I’ll breakdown each one and why this movie
seemed to fail for me.
Tension
Some say that Heath Ledger’s performance was what made The
Dark Knight as good as it was, which may be true, but what made the Joker such
an amazing character to watch on screen was the tension felt in the audience
whenever he showed up. With Ledgers once in a lifetime performance and Hanz
Zimmers amazing score, the Joker was able to produce a guteral nausea/excitement
whenever the Joker showed his smile on camera. Now this is my own fault for
setting the bar too high, but I was desiring the same from Bane. I wanted to
fear Bane. I wanted to feel that Bane was truly dangerous and really could kill
Batman. Hardy did his best but I was saddened to say that he was unable to
produce the same physical reaction of sweaty palms and stomach pains that I
felt while watching the Joker.
Also what added to the Jokers madness was his motive. What
made his motive scary was that there was no clear motive or goal. He was just
like a kid on the playground burning ants (or stacks of money) with a
magnifying glass. He had no method or to his madness, he just wanted to cause
chaos. When you can’t explain why someone is killing and maming people, it
makes it much more intense.
If this was the case with Bane, and all he wanted to do was show
the world he’s not fucking around by breaking Batman in half and leveling a
city that would have worked for me. But at the end of the film you realize he’s
nothing but a roided out sidekick. And worst of all, it was to a girl who
fucked Bruce Wayne on their very first date. He was just doing other
peoples bidding. It’s like taking the venom out of a snake bite.
What about sexual tension you may ask? It’s obviously the
best kind of tension and I thought Hathaway did Catwoman justice. In the end Batman
and Catwoman end up together “ happy and out of the game” only prior to
that scene there was no sexual tension and desire for each other throughout the
movie. Bruce Wayne sleeps with Miranda Tate. Wouldn’t it have made more sense
for him to bang Catwoman since they were going to end up together? Or just have
Bruce alone…because the last two woman we have seen him with either died (Rachel)
or ended up being the bad guy (Tate).
World Of Story
TDKR starts off with a crippled Wayne who has been retired
for eight years due to his belief that if people still believed in Harvey Dent,
then they’d still believe he was one of the good guys and anybody they arrested during Dents Reign
as District Attorney would remain behind bars. Fine, that’s okay and it works with me.
But if the movies coincide correctly it means in Batman Begins he took about a
year to train and become Batman. Then in Dark Knight, about a year after he
becomes Batman, Joker arrives on the scene and causes all hell to break loose.
Okay, those work for me but then The Dark Knight Rises comes along eight years
later and we’re supposed to think that everybody in Gotham hasn’t forgot about
a vigilante who existed for a little bit over a year? The ratio of Bruce Wayne
actually being Batman one year to him not being Batman eight years and we’re
supposed to believe that little children and kids of the orphanage would
probably have been four or five at the time of the Dark Knight remember who Batman
is eight years after that? We work in a business that forgets the hottest news
story within days and the media didn’t forget batman? Not to mention all the
skills and training Batman had and he just happens to be a little rusty? I
played baseball for like 10 years and I don’t know if I could hit a fastball
ever again in my life but Batman, a supposedly a regular guy, can relearn how
to kick somebody in the face in a time frame of days? Besides that what army
would legitimately shoot at someone because some lunatic threatened to blow up
the city. What country are they in? Okay, now I’m starting to babble. How
did hundreds of policeman survive underground presumably without food or water
and not die or go crazy? Finally, how did Batman get from a jail which looks
like it existed in the middle east somewhere and back into Gotham, a city in
lockdown? He did it without any bat gear and without any money…honestly I was watching
it and he showed up. I was shocked. Where the fuck did he come from?

Bare with me while I break down the ending, I’m almost done.
I promise.
For a movie that runs two hours
and forty four minutes the resolution was stunted and unsatisfying. To find out
that the main baddie you've been focusing all your energy on is nothing more
than a pussy whipped side kick who doesn't even get laid by the chick he
destroyed Gotham city for.
Even the final physical showdown
between Batman and Bane was lackluster. Batman is back from the mysterious hole
in the Earth and he's somehow stronger than ever. In a battle between Banes
army and the cops of Gotham Bane and Batman seek each other out in the middle
of an all out brawl. Batman finally gets some good shots in on Bane, breaking
his mouthpiece/ball gag. From what we learned earlier this apparatus prevents Bane
from feeling any pain from his face being ripped off years earlier so this
gives us the assumption that Bane hasn't felt pain like a normal human being in
quite some time. I thought this missed out on a big emotional moment that I
thought Nolan would have pounced on yet again he swung and missed at a curve
ball in the dirt. I didn’t like how they
let a villain that could have lived up to Ledger’s Joker, go out like a little
bitch. He gets taken out by a sneak motorcycle attack and his demise is left
largely off screen. I just thought that if you’re going to devote an hour and a
half to showing how badass a character is by allowing him to physically and
emotionally break Batman, don’t sweep his demise under the rug
As much as Chris Nolan is a master at leading his audience
to exactly where he wants them to be, he can hurt himself by making things a
little too obvious. There was a lot of talk of this being the first batman to
ever die on film. This lead to countless internet speculation about whether or
not he really was going to kill Batman. Throughout the movie it was a common
theme. Alfred gives what seems like five separate ten minute monologues to Bruce
Wayne during this movie about how he doesn’t have to fight anymore and that he’s
going to die for no reason besides his own pride. It incepted the notion into
viewers heads that “hey, we might be right- batman might die at the end of this”.
I would have been fine with that, finally seeing one of the greatest heroes of
all time sacrificing his life to finally be free. I loved that idea but Nolan
couldn’t leave it at that. He had to poke and prod and lead us to the exact
opposite. In the end (which is very much the same as the Avengers)Batman takes a nuclear time bomb that is someway
unstoppable, away from civilization to help save everybody/Gotham. Throughout
the film Batman’s new flying vehicle “The Bat” has had problems with the auto
pilot. They mentioned the damn auto pilot no less than ten times. HMMM I WONDER
IF THE AUTO PILOT IS GOING TO BE IMPORTANT??? And yes, of course instead of
thinking Batman actually died, I came to the conclusion that he probably
figured out how to do auto pilot. But granted this was a stretch for me and everyone
else because of how much Nolan set it up that Batman could/would die. At least I
had worry that the cowled one would perhaps perish.
In closing, I know I am harsh on this film, but then
again you are always the harshest on those you expect the most from. I don’t
put all the blame on the film itself, I have to put some of it on myself for
going in with unreachable expectations. I wrote this article before I got a
chance to see it for the second time, which may sway my feelings elsewhere but
for now I feel like a parent.
Not mad, just disappointed.
-Miggs
Miggs is the 2 man weave's perma-frat boy